Birmingham Criminal Defense: Loophole in Alabama Law allowed "Mentally Unstable" Individuals to Purchase Guns

Due apparently to a lack of information sharing between Alabama and federal law enforcement authorities, hundreds if not thousands of people who are barred by law from buying hand guns, rifles and shotguns may have done so with scarcely a problem. According to a recent news report, Alabama failed to report thousands of individuals who are barred from firearms possession to the federal government. This situation could have allowed persons living in cities such as Montgomery, Tuscaloosa, Decatur and Prattville to buy firearms contrary to that allowed by law.

As a Birmingham criminal defense lawyer, I help many people across Alabama who have been accused of a crime. Not all of these individuals are guilty, and all are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This latest news article points up the confusion that is sometimes caused by the lack of communication between state and federal agencies.

According to reports, Federal authorities and gun control advocates believe that literally  thousands of potentially unstable mental patients who have been released from state institutions now have easy access to guns because of Alabama's narrowly defined reporting law.

In one instance, a former West Point graduate who served 18 years in the U.S. Army walked into a local Bass Pro Shop and bought a shotgun, pistol and rifle. Police reports indicate that the instant background check run by store personnel in Spanish Fort failed to flag the customer as a person barred from buying a gun. The reason for this, say law enforcement authorities, is due to the fact that Alabama reports just a small fraction of mental health commitments to a national database.

The 42-year-old military veteran, David Otto Gluth, Jr., was previously treated for post-traumatic stress disorder at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center. Additionally, a psychiatrist who treated him at the AltaPointe Health System in Mobile, AL, stated that Gluth might also suffer from bipolar disorder with psychotic features and other problems. In 2008, he was reportedly involuntarily committed to Searcy Hospital in Mount Vernon, which made him ineligible under federal law to buy or own a gun.

Police were made aware of the potentially mentally unstable individual after he allegedly got into an argument with another customer in the store, talking about his needing a steady hand to shoot someone. A spokesman for the tore said he was confident that the company followed the law.

According to gun control advocates, if a store employee observes strange and threatening behavior from a customer it is a good indication that the gun should not be sold. This was apparently borne when Fairhope police responded to complaints of an armed man walking around the Rock Creek subdivision. They arrested Gluth and booked him on a disorderly conduct charge.

 

Gun loophole: Alabama fails to report thousands who are barred from firearms possession, AL.com, January 17, 2010

 

Birmingham Criminal News: Two Alabama Men Arrested for Posing as Private Detectives; Accused of Extortion

As a Birmingham criminal defense attorney, I have seen a wide of criminal indictments for crimes ranging from drug manufacturing and computer fraud to assault and murder. If there is one thing I am certain of, that is every citizen’s right to a fair criminal trail and to be considered innocent until proven guilty.

Just last month, two men from Lauderdale County, AL, were charged with extorting money from individuals in northern Alabama. According to news articles, the two posed on numerous occasions as private investigators using their false personas as a way to get money from their alleged victims.

The two men are reportedly both from Florence, Alabama. According to reports, 44-year-old Mark Douglas Wilson and 47-year-old Gregory Jones Harrison were charged with second-degree extortion by law enforcement authorities -- this is a Class C felony and punishable by up to 10 years in prison following a conviction. The recent arrests came following allegations against the two and a subsequent probe by the Alabama Bureau of Investigation.

Officials at the ABI allege that Harrison and Wilson presented themselves as private investigators working under contract with the ABI to conduct investigations into criminal activities. The two men are accused of attempting to extort large sums of money from the various individuals they had targeted.

According to information provided by the ABI, the suspects apparently explained to the victims that their names were included on a list of persons involved in criminal activity and that they would be arrested in an upcoming roundup by law enforcement. The extortion came in the form of promises to remove those person’s names from the fictitious list in exchange for certain payments.

Investigation into the alleged extortion arrangement commenced after the ABI was contacted by a local businessman who said he had been approached by Harrison and Wilson. The investigation reportedly lasted a little more than one week. Following the arrest the two suspects were placed in the Lauderdale County Detention Center until they were released on bail of $1,000 each.

 

Two local men charged with extortion, TimesDaily.com, January 23, 2010


 

Birmingham Crime News: DeKalb County Man Accused of Porn Video Production Loses Last Alabama Criminal Appeal

Across the state of Alabama, in towns and cities like Hoover, Phenix City, Huntsville and Dothan, individuals are arrested daily for crimes such as assault, theft, drug possession and criminal sexual behavior. As a Birmingham criminal defense lawyer, I understand the circumstances that can get a person caught up in the legal system. State and federal crimes can result in criminal convictions and lengthy jail and prison sentences.

It happens all of the time in this state and the appeals process can be critical in avoiding a life-altering conviction. Recently, the Alabama Supreme Court refused a final appeal by a DeKalb County man who was arrested for producing pornographic videos of juveniles at a business he once owned. He was convicted in 1990 and sentenced to four consecutive life terms.

According to news reports, 66-year-old David Lawrence Poole, who is currently serving his sentence at the Limestone Correctional Facility, had his final appeal denied without comment by this state’s highest court.

Based on new articles, the former owner of the Rainsville skating rink was arrested in 1989 at his DeKalb County home following complaints of a hidden camera located in a heating duct grille in the rink’s bathroom. A police investigation not only uncovered the video equipment, but by tracing the coaxial cable running from the camera to the suspect’s trailer parked next to the facility, law enforcement officials also found a cache of pornographic tapes.

Prior to this latest and apparently final attempt to appeal a guilty verdict, Poole had gone before the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals last October. The result of that last appeal was a rejection by the court to hear Poole's case.

Eight years ago, Poole petitioned the Court of Criminal Appeals claiming that he was prosecuted in violation of search warrant laws and that the indictment was flawed. The original charges included four counts of producing obscene matter depicting persons under 17 years of age involved in obscene acts. According to reports, Poole later pleaded guilty to a fifth count.

Poole was arrested after a video camera was found behind a vent grille in the ceiling of the men's room at the skating rink he operated in 1989. A coaxial cable ran from the camera to Poole's trailer next to the rink.


Producer of porn tapes loses final state appeal, AL.com, January 15, 2010


 

Birmingham Criminal News: Defense in Homicide Case Claims Fatal Shooting Death of Policeman was Alcohol-related

As an Birmingham criminal defense attorney, I have the experience to aggressively defend individuals accused of various crimes ranging from petty theft to grand larceny and domestic violence to murder in the first degree. The innocence of defendants in a criminal trial is assumed until a conviction by a jury of their peers. No matter where you live -- Tuscaloosa, Decatur, Madison, Prattville or anywhere else in Alabama -- a jury may acquit a person arrested for a crime if the evidence gathered by the police is lacking, however in the case of some offenses the facts can be quite damning.

The trial of a man accused of fatally shooting a Huntsville police officer has seen some interesting defense tactics. According to recent news articles, Kenneth Shipp was arrested following the shooting death of Officer Eric Freeman in late 2007. The defendant’s criminal lawyer reminded jurors their job was determine whether or not Freeman's death was a result of Shipp’s intention to kill the officer, or simply a tragic result of the defendant’s reported drunkenness that evening.

According to court reports, Shipp was not only intoxicated that night, but was also under the influence of pharmaceutical drugs, which has apparently been established as fact in the case.

This is a serious situation for the defendant, who faces a capital murder charge for killing a police officer in the line of duty. In fact, the prosecution had at the time for the article stated that it would seek the death penalty if the 55-year-old man is convicted.

Based on reports, the shooting incident occurred on December 14, 2007, following what has been described as a simple investigation of a possible DUI traffic accident at Bailey Cove and Weatherly roads. However, that routine drunk driving traffic stop ended moments later when Shipp allegedly shot Officer Freeman at point-blank range with a small .22-caliber pistol.

Police reports show that Shipp shot Freeman as he and another officer, Kevin Lambert, were escorting Shipp to a patrol car to wait for a DUI investigator. When a third officer arrived, he found Lambert, Shipp and another man, a former police officer, wrestling on the ground and trying to get the gun away from Shipp.

Court records indicate that other officers arriving at the scene hear the defendant yelling that he had a bomb and demanding that they shoot and kill him. Based on news reports, Shipp’s defense team questioned whether the defendant’s behavior was consistent with intoxication. In Alabama intoxication is not a defense in and of itself. But it can sometimes be used as a defense if someone is so intoxicated that they suffer from mania and clearly don't know what they are doing.

 

Defense focus: Shipp intoxication, AL.com, February 02, 2010

Continue Reading...

Birmingham Criminal Defense Lawyer News: Former Alabama Policeman Convicted of Raping Minor Stepdaughter in Mobile County

It’s tragic when a police officer, a person charged with upholding our laws, is found to have violated the public’s trust by committing a criminal offense. Further, when any officer of the court is convicted of any crime, it hurts all of us deeply. As a Birmingham criminal defense attorney, I am committed to representing individuals who as accused of crimes in Alabama, whatever that may be -- petty theft, methamphetamine manufacture, drug trafficking or sex crimes, to name a few.

Crimes involving criminal sexual behavior are particularly heinous. If committed by a law enforcement officer they become especially tragic and shocking. In a recent court case in Mobile County, a former Chickasaw, AL, policeman has been convicted of sexual assault and rape of a female family member. Sadly, the victim died in a traffic accident two years previous.

According to the news, 51-year-old Bob Ingle was convicted of the 2006 rape of his then 10-year-old stepdaughter, Rebecca McEvoy. The prosecution’s case was naturally complicated by McEvoy’s untimely death in January 2008. Ingle’s criminal defense attorney had argued that McEvoy’s death had made it impossible for Ingle to cross-examine his accuser, which is a basic right in our modern court system.

Regardless of the defense’s comments, the trial went ahead and Ingle was found guilty on several charges of sex abuse, rape and sodomy. After months of delays, the Mobile County jury convicted the former police officer on January 27 of raping his stepdaughter. Deliberations lasted less than two hours, after which Circuit Judge Michael Youngpeter ordered the Ingle to be electronically monitored while on bail awaiting sentencing on February 25.

According to reports, McEvoy first accused Ingle of sexually abusing her in 2006. Although the victim had died, the judge ruled that any statements she made to police could not be heard by the jury however other statements she may have made to friends, family and medical personnel would be admissible.

First-degree rape and sodomy are punishable by 10 years to life in prison. Sexual abuse of a child younger than 12 is punishable by up to 20 years in prison.

 

Former Chickasaw police officer convicted of raping 10-year-old stepdaughter, AL.com, January 27, 2010

Former policeman convicted in stepdaughter’s rape, AL.com, January 28, 2010

Birmingham Criminal Defense News: Mobile Teacher Arrested for Child Sex Abuse in Baldwin County, Alabama

Being accused, or worse, convicted of a sex crime can ruin a person’s life. Police and law enforcement agencies throughout Alabama regularly arrest individuals for a range of offense related to criminal sexual behavior. From Mobile and Birmingham to Huntsville and Tuscaloosa, child pornography (also referred to as kiddy porn), sexual assault, rape and other crimes of a sexual nature are some of the most stigmatized offenses recognized by the public. Defending against charges such as these takes experience and knowledge of our vast legal system.

As a Birmingham criminal defense lawyer, I have represented many individuals accused of various offenses, including sex crimes, white-collar crime and drug possession and manufacture. Every one of the cases I handle has one thing in common: the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Because citizen is guaranteed that he or she is considered innocent until proven guilty, this is a guiding principle behind out system of laws.

According to a recent news article, a Causey Middle School teacher was arrested in January on child sex abuse charges. Based on police reports, a Mobile County school official revealed that Charles Milton Lewis, Jr. had previously been accused of exposing himself to a Causey student. The accusation was apparently not proven and therefore was not included in the teacher's personnel file, according to the school system.

Lewis, as 50-year-old a science and reading teacher at Causey, was jailed on January 12 in Baldwin County on charges of sexual abuse of a child under age 12 and contributing to the delinquency of a minor, according to the sheriff's department. At the time of the news report, the man was being held in the Baldwin County Corrections Center.

According to reports, Lewis is accused of exposing himself as well as fondling a nine-year-old boy who spent an evening at the teacher’s home in July of last year. Reportedly an acquaintance of Lewis, the boy is not a student at Causey, according to a spokesperson for the Mobile County school system.

School system officials have stated that Lewis' personnel file in the system's human resources department contains no reported instances of any inappropriate behavior. According to reports, however, the accusation of sexual misconduct came to light in the form of a formal letter of complaint to the school system last fall.

However, according to a school spokesperson, the letter was not placed in Lewis’ personnel file because the central office “gets complaint letters all the time and the allegations were unsubstantiated.” School policy prohibits filing anything in personnel files that is not substantiated.

Lewis has been on paid administrative leave since January 6, following an arrest for drunken driving two days earlier. According to reports, he was involved in an early morning crash on January 4 in Baldwin County. Police say that his blood alcohol content was 0.11 percent at the time of the crash.


Teacher in sex abuse case exposed himself to Causey school student, complaint claims, AL.com, January 15, 2010

Investigation of Mobile teacher deepens, Fox10TV.com, January 14, 2010

Alabama Supreme Court Issues Stay of Execution for Man Convicted of 1994 Triple Murder in East Gadsden

Alabama’s Supreme Court recently issued a stay of execution for a convicted murderer. According to a news report, the stay was granted at the request of Robert Bryant Melson, who received a death sentence in the robbery-murder of three employees of an East Gadsden Popeye’s Chicken and Biscuit restaurant in 1994. As a Birmingham criminal defense lawyer, I have the experience to represent individuals charged with crimes such as grand larceny, assault and murder or manslaughter.

Being an Alabama criminal attorney, I hold that every person accused of a violent crime or other criminal offense is innocent until proven guilty by a court of law. This is everyone’s constitutional right and I adhere to this important rule of law. According to the news article, the execution was to be held on February 18, but has now been delayed to await the outcome of a case being considered by the United States Supreme Court.

The 38-year-old Melson was originally convicted for the slayings of restaurant employees Nathaniel Baker, 17, Tamika Collins, 18, and Darrell Collier, 23. According to reports, a fourth employee, Bryant Archer, was the only survivor of the shootings when Melson and an accomplice, Cuhuatemoc Hinricy Peraita, robbed the restaurant in April 15 of that year. Based on court records of the incident, Archer was also shot during the robbery but survived the ordeal.

Melson’s stay was granted by the Alabama Supreme Court at Melson's request so that he and his attorney could to hear the outcome of a Florida case that is currently being considered by the U.S. Supreme Court. That case reportedly involves an issue similar to Melson's case, which revolves around whether petitions were filed in a timely manner.

This stay would appear to be Melson’s last chance, since records indicate that he exhausted his final appeal last October when it was denied by the U.S. Supreme Court.


Alabama Supreme Court stays Melson's execution, GadsdenTimes.com, January 27, 2010

Birmingham Criminal Defense Lawyer Update: Lawrence County, AL, Establishes Sex Crimes Special Victims Unit (SVU)

Alabama’s Lawrence County has created a special victims unit (SVU) to specifically handle sex crimes in the area. Police regularly arrest individuals charged with criminal sexual behavior. Some, if not many, of these people are innocent. In Birmingham, Tuscaloosa, Huntsville, Mobile and all other municipalities throughout Alabama, everyone is considered innocent of a crime until proven guilty by a jury of their peers.

As a Birmingham criminal defense attorney, my job is to defend accused sex offenders in court. The latest move by law enforcement will most likely bring more arrests and indictments upon residents and other individuals in Lawrence County. According to reports, this new SVU department is expected to enhance the law enforcement activities of the Lawrence County Sheriffs Department.

In an effort to put more emphasis on sex crimes and crimes against children, the Alabama Department of Economic and Community Affairs is financing the new special victims unit. According to news reports, the unit will have two specialized investigators, both charged with investigating crimes and working within the local school system and also promoting a variety of community awareness programs.

Crimes and other areas of law enforcement to be handled by the new unit, which will be part of the department's criminal investigations division, will include domestic violence, sexual crimes and child abuse. There will be two specially trained investigators working in the unit. According to reports, the Lawrence County Sheriff’s Department has always had a “heavy volume” of sexual crimes and crimes against children, which is one of the reasons for the county forming this new unit.

The sheriff’s department said that the two investigators will also register and monitor all sex offenders. These two SVU deputies have already been closely involved with investigations involving children because they are members of the Lawrence County Drug Endangered Children Program.

 

Special victims unit to focus on sex crimes, TimesDaily.com, November 6, 2009

 

null

Birmingham, AL, Criminal Defense News: Elmore County Schools Increase Security to Protect Kids against Pedophiles

In Birmingham, Mobile, Huntsville or other Alabama cities, criminal sexual behavior takes many forms. Pedophilia is one area of sex crimes that society and law enforcement fight hard to control. An individual accused of being a sexual predator has an uphill battle to start with, but a conviction for this type of behavior will affect a person for the rest of his or her life. As a Birmingham criminal defense lawyer, I have represented numerous people arrested for sexually-based offenses, as well as other crimes, such as theft, drugs and assualt.

A recent news article pointed up the lengths that communities will go to protect their children from pedophiles. According to reports, Redland Elementary School has initiated a pilot security program with which the administrators can perform a background check on any person visiting the school by scanning the person’s driver’s license before issuing a pass to that individual.

The program is designed to protect the elementary school children against registered sex offenders, namely pedophiles. Said one law enforcement official, “A school is a candy store for pedophiles and we don’t want them shopping here.”

The system being tested at Redland Elementary is part of a visitor verification and sex offender checking system. Redland is reportedly serving as the pilot program for “QUICK ACCESS,” a Web-based system that alerts school officials if a known sex offender attempts to gain access to the school.

Pedophiles are typically prohibited by law to live or approach within a certain radius of a school. This latest system is apparently designed to root out those individuals who are currently in the sex offender database and who violate state law requiring sex offenders to stay away from areas with a high density of children, such as elementary schools and other educational facilities.

The equipment used in Redford Elementary School reportedly cost about $900. It includes a camera and a scanning/printing device. According to the article, a school staff member simply scans the visitor’s Alabama driver’s license, or types in the visitor’s name. So long as the individual is not on the sex offender database, the machine then prints out a visitor’s badge including a bar code. The system also records when visitors arrive and when they leave the school.


Security program piloted at Redland, thewetumpkaherald.com, December 4, 2009
 

Alabama Criminal Defense News: Mobile Mans Faces Murder Charge in DUI Traffic Accident Case

Being charged with the traffic death of another individual in Alabama can be a terribly stressful situation for most anyone. As a criminal defense lawyer who has defended numerous people accused of crimes in Birmingham and other parts of the state, I know that when a traffic fatality results in a murder charge, it tops the list of serious crimes. This is when you need a competent and experienced criminal lawyer to handle your case.

A recent case being brought before a local court has put a Mobile man in the defendant’s chair. According to news articles, Leon Joseph Smith was charged with murder in the drunk driving-related death of a 20-year-old motorcycle rider in 2008. Based on reports, Christopher Willis was killed on September 27, 2008, when his motorcycle slammed into Smith's car, which allegedly turned in front of the motorcycle.

Although police say that Smith was drunk at the time, the man’s defense attorney has pointed out that Willis was speeding at the time of the collision -- his bike was reportedly traveling in excess of 70mph. Police reports indicate that Willis had been dining at a local restaurant earlier in the afternoon and was headed to a friend's home to watch a football game when the crash occurred.

According to police, Smith had a blood-alcohol content (BAC) four times the legal limit in Alabama. Smith, 64, was cited for the crash that instantly killed Willis on Hillcrest Road around 4pm on a Saturday afternoon.

Emergency medical technicians responding to the accident reportedly saw Smith, who refused medical treatment, gargling mouthwash at the scene. The driver declined to take any field sobriety tests, and was subsequently arrested by the police.

News reports show that a later test revealed Smith's blood-alcohol level to be "at least" 0.365 percent.Prosecutors maintain that Smith, being drunk, showed a "reckless indifference for other people on the roadway."Alabama law allows for drivers to be charged with manslaughter or murder if they cause a fatal accident while driving under the influence.

 

Mobile man faces murder charge for traffic wreck, AL.com, December 08, 2009